Describing the Nacirema

What are 5 words that can be used to describe the Nacirema and why was each word selected?


Unique

“In this light, the magical beliefs and practices of the Nacirema present such unusual aspects that it seems desirable to describe them as an example of the extremes to which human behavior can go.”


The Nacirema customs are unique, but arguably so are the customs of any group of people across the world. Their customs seem foreign or unusual from my outside perspective, which is to be expected and doesn’t cause me to judge them, rather it accentuates the differences between my life and theirs. 



Hierarchical 

“The medicine men have an imposing temple, or latipso, in every community of any size.”


Many of their customs seem to revolve around a specific person or group of people who hold some power above others or knowledge that others don’t. This is not that different from our society, since many government positions have inherently more power than the average citizen and jobs that require high-level degrees require special skills or knowledge that many don’t have.


Spiritual

“The use of [505 begins ->] these objects in the exorcism of the evils of the mouth involves almost unbelievable ritual torture of the client. The holy-mouth-man opens the client's mouth and, using the above mentioned tools, enlarges any holes which decay may have created in the teeth. Magical materials are put into these holes.”


Their customs and practices are very reliant on a common set of beliefs, which are similar to how most cultures have a predominant religion. While some of their practices seem brutal, I think there are comparable practices seen globally, such as female genital mutilation or coal walking. 


Misogynistic 

“Female clients, on the other hand, find their naked bodies are subjected to the scrutiny, manipulation and prodding of the medicine men.”


The practices of the Nacirema are imbalanced in their treatment between men and women. While there are some mutually shared rituals, some like the hot oven are unique to women. The Nacirema likely believe in a significant divide in the roles and rights of men vs. women, which could be compared to what we see nowadays (albeit less severe) in the US.


Discontent

“Incarcerated in such a body, man's only hope is to avert these characteristics through the use of ritual and ceremony.”


The Nacirema people seem unhappy with themselves, always seeking to improve or fix their body. Using their rituals, they can “better” themselves, which shows that they believe the human body is inherently flawed from birth. They are discontent with their body and believe that fixing it will improve their life.


Part B:


  1. I described the Nacirema with the words unique, hierarchical, spiritual, misogynistic, and discontent. I think that to an extent, most of these words do apply to American culture. I do think that American culture is unique, but so is just about every other country’s culture. American culture is definitely hierarchical, we see that politicians, celebrities, and ultra wealthy people have more power and influence than the average person. I would say that a lot of America is spiritual/religious, but the word doesn’t apply to America in the way that I used to to describe the Nacirema. Dentistry/orthodontics were almost described as magical in the reading, however I don’t believe that dentistry is comparable to magic, so my use of the word spiritual doesn’t really apply. American culture certainly still is misogynistic so I believe that aspect of the reading was accurate. We still see the effects of women having unequal rights for thousands of years in every part of our culture today. I also believe that many Americans are discontent with themselves, whether about their looks, accomplishments, income, or life as a whole, so I think it fits well.
  2. I think that my use of the word spiritual to describe the Nacirema could show some ethnocentrism and bias in my description. From an outside perspective, our medical practices, like dentistry, may be hard to understand. Many of these procedures (like getting braces) are not essential for our survival, but we choose to have them done to better our appearance. While we see them as a normal medical procedure that is safe, there are certainly some dangers to it and they can inflict pain on the patient. A large majority of Americans are religious, but religion largely does not affect our medical practices, so I still don’t think the reading was entirely unbiased with its description of American culture.
  3. I’m not sure if there’s necessarily a better word instead of spiritual. Religious might work, but as I wrote about in my second answer, I wouldn’t describe American dental practices as religious. Being spiritual/religious is not a bad thing, so I’m not sure if the usage of the word was biased in that way, rather I think it was my interpretation of the reading that was biased. 
  4. Just as I didn’t understand many of the descriptions and rituals of the Nacirema, it is logical that other cultures may not understand American culture. Without being part of a culture, it is hard to be unbiased in your view of it. I know American dental practices to be safe, but someone from another culture may see it as needlessly risky as much of the procedures are unnecessary. Their perspective isn’t wrong, it’s just different from what I see. I don’t think it’s possible to be unbiased as a Cultural Anthropologist or even just as a human. We all have biases ingrained in our minds that would be nearly impossible to get rid of. These aren’t necessarily bad biases, like racism, but could be food preferences, favorite colors, or how you dress. You can certainly try to reduce your bias as much as possible, but I don’t think having no bias is possible.

Comments

  1. Test comment to make sure I set it up right.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've recorded and scored your Part A submission. I will more feedback on Friday after you have submitted Part B.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like your choice words as I feel they are good overview of the Nacirema culture. The choice of "discontent" is a broad overview of the deep complexities described in the article. I like how you went into detail of how they view the human body as inherently bad and are constantly doing rituals to make it "better". Yet, their society is unique and thrives off traditions that have been passed down from generations. Well-said!

    ReplyDelete
  4. After taking a moment to read your post, I think that we both share similar ideas when it comes to deciding which descriptive words to use. I really like how you expanded more on the hierarchal behaviors, as well as including a quote to back up your evidence. I also think it was very neat that you compared their society to our society even before you knew that it was actually written based off of ours.

    ReplyDelete
  5. No Part B submitted by submission due date.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Comment on Part B: I'll start by listing off your five words from Part A.

    Unique
    Hierarchical
    Spiritual
    Misogynistic
    Discontent (This is a noun... how about "discontented"?)

    1. "I think that to an extent, most of these words do apply to American culture."

    Sure... but Minor isn't describing the American culture in general, just a very narrow part of it, namely medical/dental care. Do you feel your words accurately describe the behaviors Minor is trying to describe as an outsider? Is brushing our teeth "misogynistic"? Is going to the dentist "spiritual"? When you go to the hospital, is that "unique"? I think "hierarchical" could describe our health care system as a whole, but not really this narrow window of American behaviors.

    2. "A large majority of Americans are religious, but religion largely does not affect our medical practices"

    Good example and well-explained. What about "misogynistic"? Now, keep in mind, Minor wrote this in 1956, but even then, lots of men were also "poked and prodded" by doctors. Today, the medical field includes both men and women, perhaps this is better now?

    3. "Being spiritual/religious is not a bad thing"

    Careful... "bias" doesn't have to be negative. You can have positive bias as well. Bias is anything that produces a false image of reality, misleading the reader. So, no, being spiritual is not a bad thing. But saying that our medical practices, based upon medical science, are "spiritual" is definitely misleading.

    Part of what I want you to understand here is that you chose these words based upon a biased narrative...Horace Minor's narrative was designed to be a biased outsider's view of this culture, so nearly all words you choose are going to perpetuate that bias. It might be better to recognize that this attempt to define a culture with individual words isn't possible in the first place. It is a futile and biased practice and doesn't reflect what anthropologists are trying to do in their jobs. As an anthropologist, your job is to not describe from an outsider's perspective but to understand a culture.. and that means starting to see it as insiders do.

    4. "We all have biases ingrained in our minds that would be nearly impossible to get rid of. "

    Correct. While Anthropologists can strive to avoid bias and practice this skill, I suggest it is just as important to be aware that our biases are deeply ingrained in our psyche and are likely impossible to avoid completely. Better to be aware of this and be receptive to those who point it out when it happens. This is one of the reasons anthropologists collaborate with others... so that they can watch out for each other's bias seeping into their work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Riley
      Your.point on how the word spiritual uses bias is a great point. It shows slight bias because you are right when you say getting braces is just for appearance. Braces are used not for survival but rather as show for other people. That is just one thing that the "Nacerima" culture does to impress others rather than do something that brings them positive gain.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How do the Zulu & Andean people adapt to their environment?

Verbal vs. nonverbal communication and how it impacts a conversation